Great Gatsby Critique Essay

The Great Gatsby A Criticism Of The Twenties (grade 11 Essay)

1465 Words6 Pages

The Roaring Twenties is considered to be a time of excessive celebration and immense corruption. The novel, The Great Gatsby, by F. Scott Fitzgerald is a criticism of American society and its values during this era of history. This criticism is first apparent in the people who go to Gatsby's parties. They get absurdly drunk, do not know who their host is and are rude by excessively gossiping about him. This commentary is also shown in the corruption of the police. Gatsby is able to pay off the police so that the activities going on at his home will go unnoticed and so that he may behave as he wishes. This criticism is finally shown in the corruption of friendship and love, the simple fact being that there is none. People use Gatsby and…show more content…

This excessiveness is shown when Nick leaves the party and observes a car accident in the front drive. Nick says,

          Then, very gradually, part by part, a pale, dangling individual

          stepped out of the wreck, pawing tentatively at the ground with

          a large uncertain dancing shoe...

          ‘Wha's matter?' he inquired calmly. ‘Did we run outa gas?'

          Half a dozen fingers pointed at the amputated wheel - he

          stared at it for a moment, and then looked upward as though

          he suspected it had dropped from the sky...At least a dozen men,

          some of them a little better off than he was, explained that wheel

          and car were no longer joined by any physical bond. (55-56)

This man in the car is so drunk he does not even realize that the car has stopped moving; furthermore, he even fails to recognize that the wheel is no longer a part of the car. The people behave carelessly and rudely at Gatsby's parties. They only go to his house

Show More

The words “literary analysis” drop from your instructor’s mouth, and you freeze in terror. The Great Gatsby is one of those books that resonates throughout the ages–that’s why you’re reading it and writing about it for your class–but you certainly don’t feel comfortable enough with the novel to write a literary analysis.

Well, don’t sweat it too much–I’ve got your back.

I’ll give you 8 helpful tips for writing a good literary analysis on The Great Gatsby. You can mix and match or simply use this list as a starting point for your own ideas.

Symbolism in The Great Gatsby

Symbolism is when an object represents something different than what it actually is. TheGreat Gatsby is full of symbolism. The two symbols I mention below are important elements within the story, and you could easily write a whole paper on just one of them.

Tip #1: Analyze the symbolism of the eyes of Dr. T.J. Eckleburg

Image by hasunkhan via DeviantArt

The eyes of Dr. T.J. Eckleburg are painted on a fading billboard in the Valley of Ashes. Many analyses quickly draw the conclusion that Eckleburg represents God, and that both are all-seeing. This is a good analysis, but let’s try to go a little deeper.

What does it say that these all-seeing eyes have no arms, legs, or mouth? Does this mean that Eckleburg, as a God-like entity,  doesn’t have the ability to punish people but to only watch their transgressions?

Also, does the fact that this is a billboard mean anything? Fitzgerald may be trying to say that consumerism was the real god of the era. The 1920s were years when consumerism was becoming more integral, taking over almost every facet of people’s daily lives. If these eyes were painted on the side of a building, that interpretation wouldn’t be the same. Writers use symbols intentionally and for a specific reason. So pay attention to the specifics!

Tip #2: Pay close attention to Fitzgerald’s use of color

Image via Vulpes Libris

Fitzgerald uses a few colors throughout the book, and their prevalence is no accident.

Green, such as the green light on the end of Daisy’s dock, represents hope for the future.

Gray, such as  in the Valley of Ashes, represents lifelessness and nothingness.

Gold and yellow are interesting and used a whole lot throughout the book. Gold is a symbol for money. Daisy, who is from a well-to-do family and who is married to a rich man is described as a “golden girl” with a voice that’s “full of money.” She has gold all around her as do many of the other rich people.

Yellow, on the other hand, is a color associated with Gatsby, as shown by his car. Yellow is almost gold but still of lesser value, which is how the other rich people in the novel view Gatsby. He doesn’t quite fit in because he’s “new money,” which in their minds is inferior.

Point of View in The Great Gatsby

There are three points of view in literature: first-person, second-person, and third-person.

  • First-person point of view is when a story is told from a character’s perspective. This involves a lot of “I” and “me” language.
  • Second-person point of view is when the author addresses the reader directly using “you.”
  • Third-person point of view is when the narrator is not a character in the story, but rather describes the lives and thoughts of all of the other characters from an outside perspective.

Tip #3: Think about why Nick is the narrator and not Gatsby.

The Great Gatsby is written from the perspective of Nick Carraway. The story would be very different if it was told from Gatsby’s perspective. Instead, Nick guesses at the life and thoughts of Gatsby, making Gatsby seem more mysterious and larger-than-life than he would be if the reader knew all of his thoughts.

Tip #4: Analyze why the story is written in first-person.

The story would also be very different if it was told in the third-person point of view. A third-person point of view would give the reader a necessarily more honest description of events. Nick describes himself as honest, but how does the reader know that events took place exactly as Nick describes them? Is Nick an unreliable narrator?

Allegory in The Great Gatsby

Allegories are stories in which the characters and/or plot symbolize larger concepts. In The Great Gatsby, the larger concept I’ll focus on is that of the American Dream. Other allegorical concepts you could address include commentary on the social class divide or the vapidity of high society.

Tip #5: Think about what this book says about society, specifically as it relates to the American Dream.

In the 1920s, the American Dream was the idea of going from rags to riches. However The Great Gatsby shows that this dream is unattainable.

Gatsby achieves the so-called American Dream by building his wealth over the years in whatever way he possibly could. He displays his wealth with lavish parties but never enjoys himself. He is unsatisfied with the shallowness of the upper class, and yearns for something more.

While Gatsby’s rags to riches background is a literal interpretation of the American Dream, Daisy is a more symbolic interpretation. As mentioned above, she is described as a “golden girl,” representing riches. Gatsby has always longed for her, but when he finally gets her to admit her feelings for him, he still isn’t satisfied. He wants more–he wants her to say that she never loved Tom.

Fitzgerald uses Gatsby to show that the American Dream is unattainable–the dream can never become reality because the dreamer always wants more. Gatsby was not satisfied when he became wealthy or when he finally got Daisy because he still wanted something more.

Character Analyses in The Great Gatsby

There are plenty of characters you can analyze in The Great Gatsby–Nick, Daisy, Myrtle, Tom, or Gatsby himself. Each character has different qualities and characteristics, and they were all put into the story  for a reason. It’s your job to find out what that reason was.

Tip #6: Don’t just describe characters, but write about what they represent.

Each character has certain personality traits that represent a facet of human nature. Daisy, for example, represents innocence, while her husband, Tom, represents the evil of what we would call the “one percent” today.

Each of these characters was created in the mind of the author not just to make a good story, but also to offer a glimpse into the human condition. Tap into the meanings behind the characters, and you’ll have a pretty spectacular analysis.

Tip #7: Analyze the relationships between characters.

People don’t live in a vacuum–they interact with and react to other people around them. And the characters of The Great Gatsby are no different. You could analyze the nostalgic love between Daisy and Gatsby, the rocky relationship between Daisy and Tom, and the adoring (and sometimes contemptuous) relationship between Nick and Gatsby.

Focusing on the relationships between the characters makes for a great literary analysis because characters are essential to a great piece of literature.Therefore, understanding them and their relationships is also important.

Tone in The Great Gatsby

The tone of a story is how the author or narrator describes the events and other characters. It can be cynical, witty, bright, optimistic, pessimistic, or something else.

Many words you would use to describe a person’s personality can also be used to describe the tone of a story.

Tip #8: Analyze the tone of the novel.

First, decide what the tone of the novel is. Then write about how the tone affects the readers’ perceptions of events and characters.

Some readers describe the tone of The Great Gatsby as cynical, some say it’s judgmental–but you can decide on your own how you might describe the tone of the story. More important than the exact wording of how you describe the tone is how the tone affects the reader’s perception of what’s going on.

Because The Great Gatsby is told in the first person, there is some bias in what the narrator describes. We are presented with Nick’s feelings and perspective as if it’s the truth without any way of getting a different perspective.

Therefore, Nick’s tone as a narrator portrays his overall feelings about the people and events he describes and changes the way the reader experiences them.

Final Thoughts on Your Analysis of The Great Gatsby

Symbolism, allegory, point of view, character, and tone  are not even half of the types of analyses you could do, but hopefully they’re enough to get you started. Check out this site for a comprehensive list of literary devices that you could analyze.

Need more help? Look at these example essays on the The Great Gatsby to see how other students have tackled their analyses.

If you’re afraid your literary analysis still doesn’t go deep enough, or if you just need a second pair of eyes (not Dr. Eckleburg’s), send your analysis to one of the Kibin editors. They’ll be able to make your essay shine.

Happy writing, old sport.

Psst... 98% of Kibin users report better grades! Get inspiration from over 500,000 example essays.

0 Thoughts to “Great Gatsby Critique Essay

Leave a comment

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *